Forum

Please or Register to create posts and topics.

July 2025 Art Farmer - Portrait of Art Farmer

The music on the rip is not actually Portrait of Art Farmer. With the magic of acoustID I correctly identified it as Booker Ervin's Structurally Sound. If you did rip Portrait in July, I'd be excited to hear it.

Thanks for the jazz needledrops, you've provided hours of joy to me and countless more to others.

ecomaniac and wow1968 have reacted to this post.
ecomaniacwow1968

Good catch!

@squirrellydan: I got a comment in my spreadsheet that I should change the link to Mono. I rather add your information to "comment".
Can you confirm 100% that it's Booker Ervin - Structurally Sound? And is it mono or stereo?

I can confirm he's correct.  I have the Sept 25 week 1 Booker Ervin rip and and this latter rip matches it.  However, I've analyzed both and it's not the same rip. I assume it's the same vinyl, but ripped using Patrick's newer lineage.  It is mono - just look at the file size.

Quote from wow1968 on December 4, 2025, 7:14 pm

@squirrellydan: I got a comment in my spreadsheet that I should change the link to Mono. I rather add your information to "comment".
Can you confirm 100% that it's Booker Ervin - Structurally Sound? And is it mono or stereo?

That was my comment. Apologies for the confusion -- when I wrote that last night, I assumed it was just the wrong version. It wasn't until this morning when I wanted to compare a track against a YouTube version that I realized it was a completely different record.

You may know this already, but if you use macOS or Linux, you can use the "ffmpeg" program to confirm beyond doubt whether an audio track is stereo or mono:

ffmpeg -i [FILE] -filter_complex "stereotools=phasel=1" -ac 1 'output.wav'

This interpolates the left & right channels, outputting the result as a mono .wav file. If "output.wav" is totally silent, you have a mono track! To be completely thorough you could rewrite that into a bash for loop & generate spectrograms, but I haven't found that necessary.

ecomaniac and wow1968 have reacted to this post.
ecomaniacwow1968
Quote from squirrellydan on December 4, 2025, 9:01 pm

You may know this already, but if you use macOS or Linux, you can use the "ffmpeg" program to confirm beyond doubt whether an audio track is stereo or mono:

I use Audacity in Windows and wrote a macro for checking mono but thought it simpler for @wow1968 to just note the zipped file size here is too small for stereo for most full length 24-96 albums.

wow1968 has reacted to this post.
wow1968

Thanks to you both. I have removed link for the Art Farmer rip, added a comment and highlighted it with orange.

btw...using Debian Linux

squirrellydan has reacted to this post.
squirrellydan

RIP REMOVED